And/or filter trouble

On my record pages I have a list of records linked to the record page. The list is supposed to show records linked to the source (record page) record in 1 of 5 linked record fields. That behavior works fine, IF on of the 5 fields is linked to the source record. If none of the 5 fields are linked to the record in question is shows all records as opposed to none. Any ideas what is going wrong?